Russell Brand’s fall from celebrity stardom has been a long time coming. Like other powerful men whose sexual offending has eventually caught up with them, Brand enjoyed years in which his behaviour towards women was seemingly tolerated, even celebrated, as part of his public persona. His promiscuity, outrageousness and disregard for boundaries were packaged as rebellious charm, with his excesses explained away through the familiar narrative of addiction.
Now convicted of rape and three counts of sexual assault and sentenced to ten and a half years in prison, Brand’s history of sex addiction, and his claims of recovery and spiritual transformation, invite a rather different interpretation.
The suggestion that his addiction explains his behaviour towards women is, to my mind, absurd. It confuses three psychologically distinct phenomena: addiction, narcissism and sadism. While these can coexist within the same individual, they are not interchangeable, and overcoming one does not mean that the others have disappeared.
What is sex addiction?
Strictly speaking, sex addiction is not formally recognised as an addictive disorder in the DSM-5-TR, although the World Health Organisation recognises Compulsive Sexual Behaviour Disorder as an impulse control disorder.
From a psychoanalytic perspective, compulsive sexual behaviour can be understood as an unconscious attempt to regulate emotional states that the individual struggles to tolerate. Sex may become a means of escaping anxiety, shame, loneliness or an underlying sense of inadequacy. What appears to be an insatiable sexual appetite may have relatively little to do with sex itself, but rather represent an attempt to meet emotional needs that cannot be recognised or expressed in other ways.
However, an overwhelming compulsion towards sex does not require someone to violate another person. Sexual desire, however intense, does not explain the disregard of consent, nor does it account for the humiliation and degradation of others.
Russell Brand’s narcissism
Brand’s narcissism is hardly a revelation arising from his criminal convictions. His grandiosity, entitlement, insatiable need for attention and tendency to dominate interactions have been features of his public persona for decades, remarked upon by countless journalists and interviewers. Brand himself has acknowledged his narcissism.
Narcissism has become something of a cultural obsession, reduced in popular discourse to vanity, arrogance or excessive self-confidence. Psychoanalytically, however, narcissism is considerably more complex. Behind the grandiosity often lies a fragile sense of self that relies upon admiration, validation and control to protect against intolerable feelings of inadequacy and shame.
One consequence of this psychological organisation is that other people become less important as individuals in their own right and more valuable for what they can provide.
They exist to admire, reassure, gratify or otherwise serve the narcissistic individual’s needs.
In Brand’s case, I would argue that his longstanding public persona demonstrates precisely this pattern of narcissistic entitlement. The evidence presented at his trial portrayed a man whose desires took precedence over the autonomy of the women he assaulted. Their right to refuse appears to have been of little consequence. There is something profoundly omnipotent about this position. Ordinary boundaries are experienced as applying to other people, while one’s own desires assume a privileged status. Celebrity and power can only reinforce such a position, particularly when those around the individual become accustomed to accommodating behaviour that would otherwise be unacceptable.
However, narcissism alone does not explain the darker aspects of Brand’s offending.
Sadism is something altogether different
Narcissism and sadism are not synonymous, although they can exist alongside each other within the same personality.
A narcissistic individual may exploit another person because their own needs are paramount and the feelings of others are largely irrelevant. A sadistic individual, by contrast, derives gratification from another person’s suffering, humiliation or powerlessness.
For the narcissist, another person’s suffering may be incidental to getting what they want. For the sadist, the suffering is part of what they want.
Sadism need not be sexual. It can manifest through emotional cruelty, intimidation and degradation. Psychoanalytically, it may represent an attempt to rid oneself of intolerable feelings of weakness or vulnerability by locating them in another person, who is then made to experience the very feelings the sadist cannot bear within themselves.
My interpretation of Brand’s offending is that it raises serious questions about sadistic characteristics alongside his narcissistic entitlement. His proven coercive and violating behaviour, considered in the context of his wider treatment of women, suggests a relationship with power and aggression that cannot adequately be explained by sexual compulsion. Whether the suffering of his victims was itself gratifying to him cannot be established from his convictions alone.
A heroin addiction may compel someone to seek heroin at considerable personal cost. It does not, however, compel them to physically attack and humiliate elderly people in pursuit of it. Were they to behave in this way, we would rightly question their relationship with aggression and cruelty rather than simply attribute their actions to addiction.
The same applies to sex addiction. Compulsion does not explain cruelty.
Addiction is not a personality
Perhaps the most troubling aspect of Brand’s narrative of recovery is the suggestion that having overcome his addictions, he has fundamentally transformed himself.
People can and do recover from addiction, sometimes through profound psychological change. However, abstinence does not necessarily alter the underlying personality structure through which someone relates to other people.
A narcissistic individual may stop using drugs or compulsively pursuing sex while remaining every bit as entitled, grandiose and exploitative as before. Likewise, sobriety does not resolve sadistic tendencies or fundamentally change someone’s relationship with aggression.
Indeed, the identity of the recovering addict, spiritual teacher or redeemed individual can itself become another means of meeting narcissistic needs. The admiration once sought through celebrity or sexual conquest may simply be pursued through a different identity.
There is also a fundamental distinction between guilt and shame. Guilt involves recognising the suffering we have caused another person, while shame is concerned primarily with our experience of ourselves as damaged or exposed. Someone may feel enormous shame at their public downfall without necessarily experiencing genuine
concern for those they have harmed.
The danger of explaining Brand’s offending primarily through addiction is that it shifts attention away from the women he abused and towards his suffering, recovery and redemption. They become unfortunate casualties of his struggle rather than individuals whose autonomy and humanity were disregarded.
As psychotherapists, we seek to understand the unconscious processes that drive destructive behaviour, but understanding is not the same as excusing.
Brand may have overcome his addictions, but that tells us remarkably little about whether he has confronted the narcissistic entitlement and potential sadism that offer a more troubling interpretation of his behaviour.
Addiction may explain why someone cannot stop pursuing what they want. It does not explain why they believe they are entitled to take it, regardless of the suffering they cause.
Share this article
- Filed under: Brighton and Hove Psychotherapy, Mark Vahrmeyer, Mental health
- Tagged with: compulsive sexual behaviour, Narcissism, narcissistic entitlement, narcissistic personality traits, personality disorders, psychoanalysis, psychology of addiction, Russell Brand, sadism, sex addiction, sexual offending, sexual violence

About the Author
Mark Vahrmeyer is a UKCP-registered psychotherapist working in private practice in Hove and Lewes, East Sussex. He is trained in relational psychotherapy and uses an integrative approach of psychodynamic, attachment and body psychotherapy to facilitate change with clients.
To enquire about psychotherapy sessions with Mark Vahrmeyer click here, or to view our full clinical team, please click here.
